Ordering a cake is as simple as 1-2-3!

Step 1

Choose from 3 different delicious cookie crusts:

Chocolate

Chocolate & Peanut Butter

Vanilla with Chocolate filling

Step 2

Choose any two flavors of Ice Cream of your liking. Some of Effie's most popular flavors are listed below:

Mint Chocolate Chip

Peanut Butter

Snickers

Banana Split

Coffee

Chocolate Chip

Heath Bar

Neopolitan

Strawberry

Peppermint (a Christmas-time favorite)

other (use your imagination)

Step 3

Choose your topping.

Homemade fudge sauce

Homemade fudge and peanut butter sauce

If you can't decide on the flavors or the crust, just ask Effie for help. Each cake is made from scratch when you place your order. Just call us as soon as you decide on your style cake(s) so we can discuss delivery time. All cakes are packaged in reusable aluminum baking pans with sealed lids for freshness.

Note: prior to adding the topping of your choice, you can request the "MJ special". The MJ special is an extra layer added to our typical cake. We place a cookie crust beneath the fudge and first layer of ice cream. Give it a try.

NEW! Effies now makes chocolate chip cookies and brownies as well to compliment her cakes. Consider ordering a batch of one of these home made treats and you can satisfy the sweet tooth of everyone in the family.

Sizes & Prices

Cakes come in two sizes:

13 x 9 inches - serves 15 - 20 people - $25.00

9 x 9 inches - serves 8 - 10 people- $15.00

Shipping and handling will apply for out of town orders. We accept check, Visa, and MasterCard.